MyFox
 

car7858det2ghp's Blog

by car7858det2ghp from Michigan

Last Post 84 days, 14 hours Ago


 

Shut down Detroit's dropout factories

Bulldozers ought to be rolling across Detroit, leveling public schools that are trapping children in poverty and ignorance. An army of civil rights lawyers ought to be marching up the steps of the federal courthouse on behalf of students being denied their basic right to a decent education by a chronically incompetent school system. No other response is adequate to the report that Detroit Public Schools graduates just 25 percent of its students. That news last week should have rocked this city with outrage. It isn't just a cold statistic -- its thousands of children each year who are washed out of the game before they even reach adulthood. Most will end up either in prison or on welfare. The link between the dropout rate and the crime and poverty rates is indisputable. Seventy percent of Michigan prison inmates are high school dropouts, as are 40 percent of the state's welfare recipients. And most will be supported by taxpayers their entire lives.

Detroit School Superintendent Connie Calloway has a plan to dismantle five of Detroit's worst schools and replace them with smaller, more responsive schools staffed by new administrators and teachers. Good for her. But Calloway is counting on those responsible for the current failure to implement her new strategy. Maybe she has enough dedicated, student-minded educators on staff to make the five chosen schools work. But what about the rest?

No additional evidence is needed to conclude the Detroit Public Schools can't be fixed. Three decades of one reform effort after another have produced a district with the worst big-city dropout rate in America. Detroit Public Schools should cease to exist as a teaching body. Calloway has the power under the federal No Child Left Behind Act to close any school that hasn't met performance standards for six years. Nearly every school in Detroit falls into that category. She should shut down those schools and fire everyone in them. She should replace the DPS schools with highly accountable schools run by private vendors screened, hired and monitored by the district, and free to hire teachers and principals whose jobs depend on producing better results.

The Detroit school system could still operate the handful of schools that are meeting federal standards, but even those would benefit from being spun off. The corrupt contractors, parasitic preachers and union do-nothings who have sucked the district dry will try to make shutting down any school district building into a racial issue, as they always do. But I can't think of anything more racist than denying Detroit's predominately African-American students the same education that their white, suburban counterparts take for granted. Not another dime of taxpayer money should go to subsidize this failure. Nor should the future of another Detroit child be destroyed by a school system that will never get it right.

If a 25 percent graduation rate doesn't make Detroit parents angry enough to demand radical change from the education system, nothing will.

10 Comments |  Add a Comment

Member Comments Total Comments: 10
Page 1 of 1
cook2712 read my blog view my photos
Apr 7, 2008 | 4:00 PM

Home schooling is the answer. Dont have them if you cant educate them and provide what they need. Dont depend on a failing government or state agency to raise your children for you. !!!

cindykay54 read my blog view my photos
Apr 7, 2008 | 4:44 PM

You said it Cook. Sounds like the way Guilford County schools are headed. I have never seen so many students that have no clue as to what they should know when they graduate...and my question is....how do they get in to college without a proper education??? I have actually talked to college students that have no idea what or where the state capital of NC is and they were born, raised, and (cough-cough) educated here. The youth of today are not getting a third of the education I did because of the so-called "dumbing down" of America. This is sad thing and it is going on in all 50 states.

car7858det2ghp read my blog
Apr 7, 2008 | 6:53 PM

Good points cook2712 and cindykay54; Our children these days seem more like their going through the system whether they have learned anything or not. If this is the case, our future generations are in for one big letdown when it comes to having qualified people working in their businesses.

HankHill read my blog
Apr 8, 2008 | 9:11 AM

Home schooling is not the answer because many parents do not have the ability or the luxury to do this for their kids. Giving a child what they need is one thing, but saying “don’t have the kids if you can’t educate them” is something else.
A school system that is failing does so with the educational process. It fails our society. It fails the children.
Truly schools should not be expected to raise the children, but they do. Many children, right here in Guilford County, get more attention, love, care and direction from teachers, councilors and administrators who do care and want the best for these kids.
Teachers are not allowed to teach, but required to teach to the required tests. Testing over and over and over and this is where we are. Thank “No Child Left Behind ”
Demand the Removal of the No Child Left Behind Act. We can’t stand any more of this mentality.
School Boards should be held accountable. Of Course now GCSS is asking for Millions on bond referendums and they will make you feel guilty saying it is all needed for the kids. When the truth of the matter is they are not thinking or acting in a responsible manner. GCSS has facilities sitting empty. Failing school systems need to be held accountable because they are charged with educating our youth. Say NO to the bonds.
Here in Guilford County there are problems brought on by parents. For instance a year or so ago Grimsley High School was attempting to create a 9th Grade Academy to assist with the transition of 9th graders from middle school to high school. But a group of parents shot the idea down. These

HankHill read my blog
Apr 8, 2008 | 9:12 AM

These parents were thinking only of themselves, their kids and their circumstances and not the picture as a whole. Smith High School on the other hand developed a 9th Grade Academy. Check the drop out rates of 9th graders compared to that of upper classmen in our Guilford County High Schools. This statistic alone dictates the need for 9th Grade Academies in every one of our high schools.

JQPublix read my blog view my photos
Apr 9, 2008 | 4:35 PM

Hank I think academies are a way to deal with the problem but it is like putting a suture on a wound. It stops the bleeding but still doesn't confront the cause.

mayberryman
Apr 10, 2008 | 9:16 AM

I think the problem is multi-fold. First, the problem with the American public education system is the fact that we try to educate everyone. And that is unrealistic--some students are simply uneducable. Secondly, you have administrators that are politicians rather than educators. It is their job to appease mommy and daddy, even if the kid is clearly in the wrong. Take, for example, the art teacher in Baltimore that was assaulted by her student. 20-1 says the conversation in the principal's office went something like this: "Now, Ms. X, when you asked the student to sit down and behave, what was the pitch of your voice? Could it be interpreted as hostile? Did you stop to consider that the student may have been having a bad day, has problems at home, etc.? The administration had deciced that (A). This incident will go down as a reprimand in your file, and (B). You are to issue a formal apology for your behavior to the student, the student's parents, and the class, assuring them that this will never happen again." I'm almost positive that's the way it went, because I've seen it happen before. I wonder, homeschoolmom--what do you think about this subject/incident in Baltimore?

DW45 read my blog view my photos
Apr 10, 2008 | 6:33 PM

We can't blame it all on the School Systems/ Teachers.....They aren't holding their end of the PACT, but there's an awful lot of PARENTS who SHOULD have been "left behind"...

This is gonna take a lot of fixin'.....

FarmTruk read my blog view my photos
Apr 12, 2008 | 12:14 AM

This is Detroit we're talking about now. Come on, people...

I think rather than blaming the schools, the blame should fall on the extreme levels of unemployment, poverty, and single-parent households. You can't blame the schools for not being able to teach those who choose not to be taught, or are not encouraged to get an education.

Axekick read my blog view my photos
Apr 18, 2008 | 5:13 PM

I think good bad right or wrong we have not seen the effects of home schooled children I know of one case were we have had a mass murder who was a “quote unquote” good upbringing home schooled child. I feel time will tell and show the effects of this isolation during their youth and it will show up in the work place and in the community one poster here told another that maybe if they would get out more he could make friends I’m paraphrasing but it sounded reasonable to me, that this fellow seems to be a internet hermit that does not function well with live human beings. I think we lack sufficient data on home schooling to determine whether is good for society. An interesting note that home schooled child killed his parents.

Page 1 of 1


Write your comment below:




car7858det2ghp

I am presently disabled due to a work injury in the construction field. I was born & raised in Detroit for over 40 years. I presently reside in Macomb County, in recovery since April 4, 2004. I tend to post & reply from actual experiences and topics that lean towards informing people about positive things, while making sure that the real story isn't lost in the shuffle. My posts & comments are my opinion, letting you be the judge based on the issue & current events. (Good ole Disclaimer stuff). I am all for America & Americans, but not for government control & political games. I don't candy coat nothing & give what I receive. Life is too short to play mind games or waste my time with negativity. Welcome! BTW, I now blog in 12 other sister MyFox websites, along with my home blogsite of MyFox Detroit-WJBK, as follows: Cleveland--WJW, Boston--WFXT, D.C.--WTTG, Greensboro High Point N.C.--WGHP, Atlanta--WAGA, Birmingham Alabama--WBRC, St. Louis--KTVI, Twin Cities--KSMP, Tampa Bay--WTVT, Milwaukee--WITI, Chicago--WFLD, New York--WNYW, and Memphis--WHBQ. One way to stay in recovery & keep busy!

Member Since: 3/18/2008